Fifth Business
I. Basics:Author: Robertson Davies
Setting: Mainly Deptford, Canada but also in the battlegrounds of World War I, Europe and Mexico.
II.) Characters:
Dunstan: The main character of the story yet ironically, Dunstan considers himself to be fifth business a character who is not the hero but nonetheless important.
Mrs. Ramsay: Mrs. Ramsey takes on the archetype of the ill-tempered mother. Her efforts to mold her son often have the reverse effect and she feels constant frustration with him.
Mary Dempster: She takes on the Jungian archetype of the fool saint, the mother and the sacred feminine. Although Dunstan regards her as divine, the town of Deptford wholly rejects her, fitting the archetype of the fool saint and also the sacred feminine. Dunstan also speaks of Mary more tenderly than his own mother and regards her as a source of wisdom and advice.
Paul Demster: While Dunstan is wholly preoccupied in shaping his life’s story around Boy, he fails to realize that a more powerful story is underway. Paul, fitting the Jungian archetype of the magician also carries many allusions to Jesus. This suggests an interesting theme of the importance of perspective.
Boy Staunton: The original snowball thrower, since that moment Boy and Dunstan have led inseparable lives. Although Dunstan shapes his story around Boy, he fails to realize a greater story is happening around Paul.
Padre Blazon: Dunstan’s confidante, he encourages Dunstan along his path to self-realization.
Lisel: Representing the high priestess, a manifestation of the devil, or the watchmaker god, Lisel acts to help Dunstan realize what he believes is his purpose and to make Paul’s magic sparkle. She is forever behind the scenes acting as god the watch-maker for the Jesus-like Paul.
The story starts with the the snowball that hits Mary Dempster and leads to Paul’s birth. Guilt-ridden, Dunstan acts as a caretaker for Mary who has slipped into insanity after Paul’s premature birth and a friend to Paul, teaching him magic tricks and reading him stories. One day, Mary goes missing, only to be found consensually have sex with a tramp. This scandal pushes the Dempsters into social disgrace and they become ostracized by all of Deptford except Dunstan. Dunstan continues to visit, and when his brother dies, Mary performs and brings him back to life. Shocked by his continued association with Mary, Dunstan’s homelife deteriorates until eventually he decides to enlist in the army. In the army he performs well and wins a medal called a VP although he is wounded. While recovering he meets a woman named Diana who convinces him to change his name, and thus he is born again. Eventually he returns to Canada where he learns that Paul ran off to join the circus and Mary slipped further into insanity and now lives with her aunt. Dunstan takes a job as a teacher and during his breaks studies saints. During the war, Dunstan caught sight of a Madonna figure and finding that statute has compelled Dunstan on a mission to traverse Europe for it. While in Europe Dunstan runs into Paul who is now a brilliant magician, though his talents go unappreciated. Dunstan continues to maintain his relationship with Boy and watches as Boy’s homelife collapses. Meanwhile, Dunstan continues his obsession with saints and his search for the Madonna and along the way meets Padre Blazon who acts as his confidante. Paul’s travels next lead him to Mexico where he again finds Paul as a magician but this time his show is filled with wonder and mystery. The reasoning behind this is the support of Lisel who counsels Dunstan on his own life. With her help, Dunstan begins to realize his place in the world. Dunstan then returns to Canada and follows as Boy makes more destructive moves for his family. Then he flashes to Boy’s mysterious death that suggests to be the work of Paul.
IV.) Narrative Voice/Author’s Style
POV: Dunstan, the main character, tells the story from his perspective. The novel is written in first person, and although Dunstan intends for the memoir to be objective and to contain no bias, it inevitably does.
Tone: The tone is light, comedic and a bit bitter. Dunstan intends to prove that his life was worthwhile, but this does not go without a tinge of self-importance and bitterness.
Symbolism: Jungian archetypes, the blending of reality and the mystical, magic, synchronicity
V.) Quotes:
"This is one of the cruelties of the theatre of life; we all think of ourselves as stars and rarely recognize it when we are indeed mere supporting characters or even supernumeraries."
We have often discussed that in order for a book to have a satisfying ending, it must come full circle, and this quote in the beginning sets up Fifth Business to do so. This quote relates entirely to the theme of perspective. Sure, we might all be fifth business in someone else’s story, but aren’t we all the main characters of our own? Regardless of which story is greater, I think that Dunstan neglects this point though his readers don’t.
“The inevitable fifth, who was the keeper of his conscience and the keeper of the stone.”
This quote, stated by Lisel at the end of the novel, reinforces the importance of Dunstan’s position in both the stories of Paul and Boy. Through these words, Davies reiterates his theme of the power of even the most unseeming.
VI.) Themes:
Perspective determines whether you are the main character or not in your own story.
As aforementioned, Dunstan writes his letter on the premise that he is Fifth Business. However, his story is still his story, and thus he is its main character. Although he might be a different character in someone else’s story, his still stands. Furthermore, even though Dunstan frames his memoir around Boy, biblical allusions involving Paul suggests that an even greater story revolves around him.